探索与争鸣 ›› 2019, Vol. 1 ›› Issue (11): 4-41.

• 圆桌会议 • 上一篇    下一篇

数字加密货币:新兴技术、货币体系与全球秩序——Libra倡议下数字货币的未来(黄奇帆、戴金平、何平、袁志刚、潘英丽、葛劲峰、易宪容、乔依德、许多奇)

黄奇帆、戴金平、何平、袁志刚、潘英丽、葛劲峰、易宪容、乔依德、许多奇   

  • 出版日期:2019-11-24 发布日期:2019-11-24

Cryptocurrency: Emerging Technologies,Monetary System and Global Order ——The Future of Digital Currency Under the Proposal of Libra

  • Online:2019-11-24 Published:2019-11-24

摘要: 2019年6月18日,互联网巨头Facebook发布稳定币Libra白皮书,宣称其使命在于“建立一套简单的、无国界的货币和为数十亿人服务的金融基础设施”。8月2日,中国人民银行召开2019年下半年工作电视会议,强调加快推进我国法定数字货币(DC/EP)研发步伐,追踪研究国内外虚拟货币发展趋势。而早在2017年底,有外媒便推测 “IMF拟根据特别提款权(SDR)机制,推出一个类似比特币的全球数字货币IMFCoin,旨在取代现有储备货币”。在比特币等数字货币乱象丛生、依然处于风口浪尖的当下,这一系列紧锣密鼓的以区块链等新兴技术为支撑的数字货币计划若付诸实施,将滋生哪些经济风险?对现行货币体系带来哪些冲击?其在多大程度上可能会改写既有金融规则?又在何种意义上构筑和形塑新型世界秩序?日前,《探索与争鸣》编辑部和上海市人民政府决策咨询研究基地袁志刚工作室、上海社科院互联网研究中心联合召开了“数字加密货币:新兴技术、货币体系与全球秩序”的圆桌会议,希冀深入探究去中心化、超主权、跨国界的私人数字货币的本质特征、发展趋势与新型风险,以及未来央行法定数字货币之于中国乃至世界的意义。
黄奇帆副理事长认为,数字化拥有的五全基因与金融碰撞以后,在个人支付方式、贸易清结算体系、全球货币发行机制、产业链运营效率四个方面重塑了金融生态。戴金平教授重新定义了新型数字货币的内涵,认为中央银行发行的数字货币属于第三代数字货币。她强调,数字货币发展的理想结局是货币的消亡,目前的过渡状态为有限信用+有限信息的数字货币。何平教授认为,作为网络虚拟社区货币,比特币和其他形式的私人数字货币否定了货币的本质,存在根本性缺陷。私人数字货币极端化的Libra将成为金融梦幻,但它加速了央行法定数字货币的探索和创新。袁志刚教授指出,美元危机是这个世界未来最大的危机,全球正在面临安全资产的严重短缺,全球数字货币的广泛运用或将有助于一种国际安全货币的创造。潘英丽教授认为,货币本身存在内在矛盾,数字货币全球兴起的一个重要背景在于现行国际货币体系的隐性危机。数字货币可能成为“拐杖”,助力人民币国际化。葛劲峰讲师认为,央行数字货币由于对不同形式的货币形成替代,将对金融体系产生重大的结构性影响。当下,央行数字货币存在法律、隐私权、技术等屏障,其发行与使用必须限制在一定范围内进行试验再完善推广。易宪容教授认为,Libra是一种支付工具而非货币,不可能成为一种超级主权货币,而央行数字货币的改革将意味着无现金货币时代的到来。乔依德副会长认为,Libra存在数据保护、个人隐私权以及金融管理等风险,可能无法通过监管机构的审查,但它还是给全球性数字货币很多新的启示。未来,全球数字货币体系可能出现美、中、欧三足鼎立的情况。许多奇教授认为,Libra的本质在于,超级平台的私权力挑战数字货币的发行权,存在重大监管困境。而走出困境需要调整思维,开展数字货币监管沙盒园试点,加强国际合作,推动区块链技术与监管技术的融合。

Abstract:

On June 18, 2019, Facebook released a white paper on stable currency Libra. On August 2, the People’s Bank of China held a working video conference, stressing to accelerate the pace of research and development of China’s legal digital currency (DC / EP). As early as the end of 2017, foreign media speculated that IMF plans to launch a global digital currency—— IMFCoin based on the special drawing right (SDR) mechanism. If the series of digital currency plans are put into practice, how will they impact the monetary system, rewrite the financial rules and rebuild the world order? What kind of economic risks will they cause? Thus, we held a round table to explore the essential characteristics, development trends and new risks of private digital currency.
  Huang Qifan believes that digitalization will reshape the financial ecology in four aspects: personal payment method, trade settlement system, global currency issuance mechanism and industrial chain operation efficiency. Professor Dai Jinping redefined the connotation of the new digital currency, and believed that the digital currency issued by the central bank is the third generation of digital currency, and the ideal outcome of the development of digital currency is extinction. According to Professor He Ping, Bitcoin and other forms of private digital currency are network virtual community currencies, which deny the essence of money and have fundamental defects. Professor Yuan Zhigang pointed out that the U.S. dollar crisis is the biggest crisis in the world in the future, and the world is facing a serious shortage of safe assets. The widespread use of global digital currency may contribute to the creation of an international safe currency. Professor Pan Yingli believes that an important background of the global rise of digital currency lies in the hidden crisis of the current international monetary system. Digital currency may become a crutch to help the internationalization of RMB. Ge Jingfeng believes that the central bank’s digital currency has barriers in law, privacy, technology and other aspects, and its issuance and use must be limited within a certain range. According to Professor Yi Xianrong, Libra is a payment tool rather than a currency, and it cannot become a super sovereign currency. According to Qiao Yide, Libra has risks such as privacy, digital protection and financial management, which may not pass the review of regulators, but it still gives a lot of new inspiration to the global digital currency. Professor Xu Duoqi believes that the essence of Libra is that the private power of the super platform challenges the right to issue digital currency.There is a major regulatory dilemma.