摘要: 区块链时代犯罪治理面临的危机,主要体现为区块链技术的“去中心化”消解了责任主体概念,“匿名性”阻塞了传统归责路径,代码自动执行排斥外部力量对犯罪过程的介入及“分布式”特征削弱了网络空间中的主权管辖等方面。我国近年对P2P网贷和网约车的治理历程,揭示了实现法律与技术之间的和谐相处之道——不能依靠管制模式和单纯的回应模式,而应通过促使法律和技术在关照彼此核心价值诉求的基础上进行双重重构来实现和谐。通过法律与技术的双重重构重塑犯罪治理根基,一方面,需要区块链技术主动维护现有法律规制秩序,为外部监管的介入提供技术环境;另一方面,现行法律应对区块链技术的“去中心化”价值保持宽容态度,建立适应区块链发展需要的法律体系。此外,还要在法律和技术层面加强国际合作,减小区块链“分布式”特征对链上犯罪管辖的不利影响。
关键词:
区块链,
智能合约,
犯罪治理,
双重重构
Abstract:
The crisis faced by crime governance in the blockchain era is mainly reflected in the following
aspects: the“decentralization”of blockchain technology dispels the concept of responsibility subject,“anonymity”blocks the traditional imputation path, code automatic execution excludes the intervention
of external forces in the criminal process and the“distributed”feature weakens several aspects of
sovereign jurisdiction in cyberspace. The governance process of P2P online lending and online car
hailing in China in recent years reveals the way to realize the harmonious coexistence between law and
technology, which cannot rely on the regulatory model and the simple response mode, but should be
realized through the double layered structure of law and technology on the basis of caring for each other’s
core value demands. Through the dual reconstruction of law and technology, to reshape the foundation of
crime governance, on the one hand, we need blockchain technology to actively maintain the existing legal
regulation order and provide a technical environment for the intervention of external supervision. On the
other hand, the current law should be tolerant of the“decentralization”value of blockchain technology,
and establish a legal system to meet the development needs of blockchain. In addition, it is necessary to
strengthen international cooperation at the legal and technical levels to reduce the negative impact of the “distributed”characteristics of small block chain on the jurisdiction of crimes on the chain.
Key words:
blockchain
,
smart contract
,
crime governance
,
dual reconstruction
赵小勇.
第四届(2020)全国青年理论创新奖征文来稿选登(一) |法律与技术如何相处:区块链时代犯罪治理模式的双重重构
[J]. 探索与争鸣, 2020(9): 149-156.
Zhao Xiaoyong.
How Can Law and Technology Get Along with Each Other: Dual Reconstruction of Crime
Governance Mode in the Era of Blockchain
[J]. Exploration and Free Views, 2020(9): 149-156.